On May 20, Spencer posted Instagram Stories captioned "Honeymooning," with a short clip—set to "Desert Roads"—of a canyon trail ride. Jarman also shared slides May 20–21 showing her view from a horse, Spencer riding behind her and a night-sky photo over a canyon labeled "Honeymoon."
The pair first connected when Spencer reviewed Jarman’s 2021 book River Kings; they later worked on digs and launched the podcast The Rabbit Hole Detectives. Their union follows previous marriages for both: it is Spencer’s fourth and Jarman’s second. Public tensions emerged in 2024 with court filings over alleged privacy breaches and accusations the couple denied.